According to posts all over the game’s subreddit, the challenge is currently bugged. Players are hoofing it up into the cold mountains, which is no easy feat in this expansive, hostile world, and the challenge just isn’t popping. Here’s one player visiting Colter in Red Dead Online as hard as possible: To see this content please enable targeting cookies. Manage cookie settings And here’s an artist’s impression of another player visiting Colter: To see this content please enable targeting cookies. Manage cookie settings If you’re looking to complete the rest of the Red Dead Online Daily Challenges, here’s where to hunt an Egret:

Here are locations and tips for catching a Longnose Gar:

If you want to shoot hats off non-player enemies, your best bet is to hogtie an NPC, as seen in this video:

If you’re looking for Prairie Poppies, here’s locations near Blackwater:

And here’s locations near Armadillo:

Thanks to Dirty Tyler for the guide videos. A recent patch also improved the animal spawn rates all across Red Dead Online’s map. While many players are reporting more animal sightings, it’s still some way off parity with the single-player experience. Perhaps the inevitable next-gen version will be the big fix the issue needs. Players have also been enjoying bonuses all across Red Dead Online this past week.